Siyuan
Privacy-first, local-first personal knowledge management with block-level bidirectional linking and end-to-end encrypted sync.
How the 7.6 was reached
- Quality of output8/10
46,546 GitHub stars with recent pushes and only 6 open issues; a very active project. github.com
- Ease of use6/10
Desktop app plus Docker self-hosting for cloud use; docs page not found. b3log.org
- Pricing value9/10
Core app free forever including commercial use, open source under AGPL-3.0; optional sync at $64 or $148 one-time. b3log.org
- API and integration quality7/10
siyuan:// protocol, JavaScript/C plugins, web clipping, and export to Markdown, Word and HTML. github.com
- Solves the problem it claims to solve8/10
Local-first, privacy-focused Markdown knowledge base with block references, backed by 46,546 stars. github.com
7.6/10 is the mean of the 5 criteria that apply. Scored on the five-criteria rubric v1, 29 September 2026. How scoring works
Pricing
- Full local use
- Block editor
- Bidirectional links
- Flashcards (FSRS)
- Docker self-hosting
- No cloud sync
- End-to-end encrypted cloud sync
- Multi-device sync
- All Free features
Key Features
- Block-based editor with 20+ block element types and inline elements
- Bidirectional block links with backlink panel and knowledge graph visualization
- Spaced repetition flashcards using the FSRS algorithm
- Database blocks with relations, rollups, and templates
- OpenAI-compatible AI integration for writing, translation, and summarization
- End-to-end encrypted sync across devices
- Self-hosting via Docker; mobile device can act as a local server
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Truly local-first — works fully offline with no dependency on cloud services
- End-to-end encryption makes sync genuinely private, not just promised
- Block-level granularity for linking is more powerful than page-level linking in most PKM tools
- Handles very large documents (millions of characters) via dynamic loading
- Affordable paid tier — cloud sync is priced well below most competitors
Cons
- UI and documentation are primarily in Chinese; English translation lags behind
- Steeper learning curve than Notion or Obsidian for English-speaking newcomers
- Smaller plugin/theme ecosystem compared to Obsidian
- Mobile app is functional but less polished than desktop
- AI features require your own OpenAI-compatible API key — no built-in AI credits
Siyuan is one of the most capable local-first PKM tools available, particularly for users who prioritize privacy and block-level knowledge organization. It punches above its price for what it offers, but its Chinese-first UX and documentation create real friction for English-speaking users. Best suited for power users comfortable with PKM concepts who want Obsidian-level control with built-in encrypted sync.
Try Siyuan →Added to scored.tools on
Show this score
Free for any tool, at any score. It shows the live score, so it changes when the score does. Paste this where you want it:
<a href="https://scored.tools/tools/siyuan/"><img src="https://scored.tools/badge/siyuan.svg" alt="Siyuan on scored.tools: 7.6/10" width="160" height="40"></a>Do you run Siyuan? Claim this page to confirm the facts, correct one or respond. It is free and never changes the score.
Siyuan Comparisons
Head-to-head comparisons featuring Siyuan.
Competitors to Siyuan
Other tools in the productivity category worth comparing.
Notion
6.6/10All-in-one workspace for docs, wikis, projects, and AI-powered knowledge management.
AnythingLLM
8.2/10All-in-one AI application for chatting with documents, AI agents, and custom models - fully private and local.
Mem0
8.2/10Persistent memory infrastructure for AI agents and applications that learns from user interactions.
Atomic
7.0/10Local-first AI-native knowledge graph that turns notes into semantically-connected insights with auto-tagging and chat.